Old Town Key West Rentals

Experience the charm and history of Key West with Last Key Realty's vacation rentals in historic Old Town. Our handpicked properties offer the perfect blend of luxury and comfort for your stay in one of the island's most iconic neighborhoods.

From cozy cottages to spacious homes with private pools, our Old Town Key West rentals accommodate couples, families, and groups. Each property is thoughtfully decorated and furnished, providing all the amenities you need to feel at home during your stay.

Stroll the streets of historic Old Town and discover the island's unique architecture, vibrant culture, and rich history. Our rentals are just steps away from world-class dining, shopping, entertainment, and some of Key West's most famous attractions, including the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, the Key West Lighthouse, and the Southernmost Point.

At Last Key Realty, we're committed to providing exceptional customer service to make your Old Town Key West rental experience unforgettable. Our team is available 24/7 to assist you with any needs or questions that may arise during your stay.

Book your Old Town Key West rental today and plan your dream vacation in paradise. Contact us for more information or browse our properties online. We can't wait to welcome you to historic Old Town Key West!

We also have vacation rentals on Duval Street, near Duval Street, within Truman Annex, and rentals in Sunset Marina.

66 properties available

You have many choices when choosing where to stay in Key West, but the most unique way to get an authentic Key West experience is by spending your vacation in a classic conch cottage smack dab in the heart of Old Town. You know what they say - “In a world full of apples, be a pineapple.” Whether you’re on a writer’s retreat or simply need an escap

Monthly Rental

A week isn't enough time in Key West! This property is available for longer stays of 29 nights+. Please adhere to calendar months if you can. (Due to strict city ordinances we can't offer it for any less time)

The Poetic Pineapple

Private Home

$165^.00 - $563^.00 / per night

Traveling to Key West with a group deserves the ultimate vacation rental home: plenty of space to stretch out and enjoy time together, separate rooms and bathrooms to enjoy privacy, a private saltwater pool and of course, outdoor lounge area off street parking for scooters, and bicycles. THE SMILING IBIS checks all of these boxes, and more. Located

HOT 26

The Smiling Ibis

Townhome

$400^.00 - $2,875^.00 / per night

SPIRIT OF KEY WEST was originally built in 1893 and features that authentic Key West charm found in other historic properties such as Hemingway’s House, Asa Tift’s manor and Truman’s Little White House. The vaulted ceilings and Dade County Pine walls harken back to a time when the cigar industry was booming and Key West featured more millionaires p

HOT 31

New Property

Fabulously Fresh New Property!!

Monthly Rental

Spirit of Key West

Private Home

$482^.00 - $1,266^.00 / per night

4 bedrooms

4 baths

8 guests

While Old Town Key West has its fair share of impressive homes, few can compare to ENVY OF THE ISLAND, a freshly built two-story private home that combines the appearance and charm of a historic Keys home with all of the modern conveniences you have come to appreciate in new construction. This head-turning property boasts five bedrooms - unheard of

Monthly Rental

Envy of the Island

Private Home

$480^.00 - $1,399^.00 / per night

This ultimate Key West dream home is nestled in the highly desirable residential Old Town neighborhood of Solares Hill, just a quick walk from Duval Street and the Historic Seaport areas. No expense has been spared in upgrading and furnishing VILLA OLIVIETTA; the most up-to-date appliances and technology can be found in each room. The comfortable a

Monthly Rental

Villa Olivietta

Private Home

$299^.00 - $1,066^.00 / per night

For a month in Key West it is ideal to harness the comforts of new construction similar to the luxuries of your own home, but keeping the true spirit of Old Town Key West and the magical surprises around every corner. This brand newly constructed home, located a stone's throw from the Southernmost Point, also backs up to the famous Butterfly Museum

Monthly Rental

Dance of the Butterflies

Private Home

$250^.00 - $791^.00 / per night

SOUTHERNMOST VISTAS has everything you’re looking for to spend an unforgettable month in Key West. This recently built multi-story home plus rooftop sun deck exudes a wonderful blend of modern and island vibes. Featuring an open living plan, a lovely heated pool, and a spacious rooftop sundeck with incredible views of the Atlantic Ocean and histori

Monthly Rental

Southernmost Vistas

Private Home

$300^.00 - $1,150^.00 / per night

4 bedrooms

3 baths

10 guests

A stay at the DUKE OF CATHERINE is fit for a Queen to bring her King! From the crisp, clean decor to the large hot tub and the spacious master bedroom, the DUKE OF CATHERINE has everything his Majesty could desire. This freshly built, professionally designed home is the perfect size for a weekend rendezvous or an extended stay with the royal family

Duke of Catherine

Private Home

$375^.00 - $1,944^.00 / per night

Throughout Key West you'll find subtle touches of coconuts; from the towering coconut palms nestled throughout the streets of Old Town to folks sipping from fresh coconuts while soaking up the sun, and now, you can add THE TOASTED COCONUT to that list. THE TOASTED COCONUT is a rare gem in the heart of Old Town Key West that captures the essence of

The Toasted Coconut

Private Home

$500^.00 - $2,621^.00 / per night

ISLAND BLISS is a classic Old Town Key West home, complete with delicate gingerbread accents, a classic Southern front porch with rocking chairs, and lush, tropical foliage tastefully surrounding the property. This beautiful, historic two-story home has been lovingly cared for and restored with a mix of modern touches and traditional Key West influ

HOT 48

Monthly Rental

Island Bliss

Private Home

$250^.00 - $728^.00 / per night

3 bedrooms

2 baths

8 guests

MODERN IN THE MEADOWS proves you can blend modern and tropical styles into a beautifully laidback yet chic home. This fabulous monthly rental shines with its high-end upgrades, refined decor and upscale accommodations. Located in the quiet, sought-after Meadows neighborhood you’ll be treated to a month of relaxation in a newly renovated home that f

Monthly Rental

Modern in the Meadows

Private Home

$275^.00 - $1,015^.00 / per night

SOUTHERNMOST HOSPITALITY VII is a luxurious private estate that occupies an entire corner of Old Town's famous Duval Street, just a block from the Southernmost Point. Don't let the address fool you... this upscale home has plenty of privacy in the spacious back yard with a tall fence surrounding the large private pool. Privacy also comes in the for

HOT 31

Southernmost Hospitality VII

Compound

$900^.00 - $6,178^.00 / per night

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

First Name

Last Name

Phone Number

Email Address

Arrival Date

Departure Date

Comments

I agree Sign me up! I agree to receive information about promotional offers and rental info via phone, email or SMS. You can unsubscribe at anytime. Privacy Policy