4-5 Bedroom Key West Vacation Rentals

Are you looking for a 4-5 bedroom rental in Key West, FL? Last Key Realty has you covered! We have vacation homes that are private homes in the most desirable locations in all of Key West Florida. Whether it is located on Duval St, a block off Duval Street, 1800 Atlantic, Truman Annex, or a location in the heart of Historic Old Town we have something for everyone. Many of our homes have private pools, full baths, and a front porch for you to enjoy the seasonally warm weather we have year-round. In addition, our homes come fully stocked with all of the appliances, linens, and comforts you can expect in a luxury vacation home in the whole Key West area. Each home is tastefully decorated to show the unique conch flavor of the area.

If you have any questions please feel free to contact one of our vacation specialists today!


Properties Available 39 properties available
For the ultimate stay in America's Paradise, what could be more perfect for your whole group than AMERICANA TROPICALE? This festive and patriotic home will promise a one-of-a-kind island experience. AMERICANA TROPICALE has 4 spacious bedrooms each complete with its own en-suite bathroom for privacy, a private saltwater pool, a fully equipped kitch
Hot HOT 37
Americana Tropicale
Private Home Pet Friendly
$688.00 - $3,722.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (313)
In the Historic Seaport area of Old Town, there is a house that will behold your eye. At first glance you'll see that HEAVENLY ZEN is beautifully maintained with carefully tended landscaping; however, nothing will prepare you for what is inside. As you walk in, you will feel an immediate sense of peace and relaxation. All of the spaces in this meti
Heavenly Zen
Private Home Pet Friendly
$375.00 - $1,360.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (44)
If you’re looking for a Florida Keys home that rivals the seaside homes found in ‘Coastal Living’ magazine, look no further! COASTAL LOVING is an inviting two-story private home that offers a relaxing vacation setting and comfortable accommodations. This easy living home combines a classic Key West design with the finest modern updates and convenie
Coastal Loving
Private Home Pet Friendly
$300.00 - $1,315.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (7)
The vacation opportunity of a lifetime awaits at CASSIE’S PARADISE. A secluded oceanfront experience, this breathtaking home sits on over half an acre and is less than 20 miles from Key West. The 4,300 sq ft interior affords your group plenty of room to spread out. The real showstopper of this home is the backyard - complete with 120 feet of privat
Hot HOT 32
Cassie's Paradise
Estate Pet Friendly
$3,800.00 - $6,740.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (6)
There’s no better way to escape the hustle and bustle of reality than by sneaking off to Key West for a taste of the island life. ELEGANT ESCAPE offers first-class accommodations in a beautiful tropical setting. From the open layout and soaring ceilings of the main house to the enticing private pool and unique guest cottage, ELEGANT ESCAPE has ever
Hot HOT 38
Elegant Escape
Private Home
$850.00 - $3,551.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (13)
Travelers from around the world would agree spending a month in Key West is truly a magical experience, especially when you find two classic conch homes made into one. This cozy compound perfectly captures the magic of the island, with its beautiful Dade County Pine walls, tropical decor, and the plunge pool waiting just outside. MARGARET’S MAGIC
Hot HOT 32
Margaret's Magic Compound
Compound Pet Friendly
$300.00 - $1,195.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 8 guests
Like many highlights of Key West, THE ADMIRAL'S ESTATE celebrates a rich history of the island while embracing a modern restoration. THE ADMIRAL'S ESTATE is a true historic Key West home, originally built for a high-ranking Naval Officer in the early 1900s. This impressive estate is armed with two living areas, a top-of-the-line gourmet kitchen, cl
Hot HOT 34
The Admiral's Estate
Private Home
$500.00 - $1,540.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (2)
THE POLYNESIAN HOUSE is an extraordinarily unique and whimsical home, designed to capture the culture and experience of island life in an upscale private home. Viewing this home from the street, you'll know immediately how the name THE POLYNESIAN HOUSE came to be; The Polynesian-style curved roofs of the two rooms sitting atop this home are the fir
Hot HOT 27
The Polynesian House
Private Home
$500.00 - $1,489.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (3)
SOUTHERNMOST VISTAS has everything you’re looking for to spend an unforgettable month in Key West. This recently built multi-story home plus rooftop sun deck exudes a wonderful blend of modern and island vibes. Featuring an open living plan, a lovely heated pool, and a spacious rooftop sundeck with incredible views of the Atlantic Ocean and histori
Hot HOT 33
Southernmost Vistas
Private Home Pet Friendly
$300.00 - $1,150.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 3 baths
Guests 10 guests
Rating 5 (2)
Spanning an exclusive corner lot in the desirable Midtown neighborhood of Key West is a stunning compound-style home designed as the ultimate vacation destination for a family or group of friends seeking privacy and quiet only a short bike ride or walk from the bustling downtown Old Town area of Key West. In addition to four spacious bedrooms, this
Midtown Mosaic
Private Home Pet Friendly
$260.00 - $970.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 2 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (9)
For many, the artistic island culture of Key West is an intricate piece of its magic. THE ARTISTS' MUSE is an ode to that notion. This home, with its rich history of artists living in residence or visiting as guests, has been recently redesigned to celebrate art, culture, and the upscale island life. A spacious main living and dining area, a brand
Hot HOT 26
The Artists' Muse
Private Home
$333.00 - $1,022.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Guests 8 guests
Rating 5 (11)
The moment you arrive at this midtown mansion, you’ll know your time in Key West is going to be special. The circular driveway and covered portico provide a grand entrance, which set the stage for what awaits you inside. At over 3,900 square feet, ISLAND OPULENCE is one of the largest private residences in Key West. This impressive ranch-style home
Island Opulence
Private Home Pet Friendly
$250.00 - $793.00 / per night
Bedrooms 4 bedrooms
Bathrooms 4 baths
Half-Bathroom 1 half-baths
Guests 11 guests
Rating 5 (3)

Tell us what you're looking for and someone will contact you with available options.

I agree